Quince Plus Size Clothing Review: An Honest Community Member Take
After I published my own Quince clothing review, I immediately received emails and comments asking what about extended sizes? I get it. My experience as a size 14/16 only tells part of the story, and Quince's extended size collection, which runs 1X–3X (US sizes 16–24), deserved its own honest look. So I did what I always do when a review is outside my size range. I asked the Wardrobe Oxygen Community to share an honest Quince plus size clothing review.
TL;DR
The Quick Version
Community member Tricia, age 52, size 1X (40″ waist, 49″ hips), reviewed 6 pieces from Quince's extended size collection. The silk skirt, silk blouse, and linen dress were standouts. The cashmere v-neck runs sheer; size down on the hoodie. The travel tote is a genuine workhorse. Overall: solid quality for the price, with a few fit caveats worth knowing.
Tricia Cornell, 52, raised her hand. She's 5'9″ and wears a 1X to 2X in Quince sizing, with a 40-inch waist and 49-inch hips. I offered Tricia store credit to pick what she actually wanted to try, not a curated PR package. She kept the clothes; I also paid her for her time. Quince had no involvement in this post and did not see it before it published.
Below is Tricia's honest review.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. Tricia received store credit and compensation for her time. All opinions are entirely her own.
Quince Plus Size Clothing Review
A few years ago I made a pledge: I was done buying from brands that don't show photos of their clothing on larger models. Why would I take a flyer on an XL based on a photo of someone who is literally half my size? Why would I try to guess how a brand cuts the hips and seat on pants or places the bust darts on larger sizes, knowing these should be significantly different from the size S shown in the photos?
At the same time, I've also been sized out of brands that were once stalwarts in my closet. While I spent most of my adult life at the top of standard size ranges, as I've entered my 50s I have floated into what many brands call their “extended” size range. (Um, thanks for extending yourself to accommodate my body, I guess?) With a 45-inch bust, 39-inch waist, and 49-inch hips, I don't buy Boden and Loft anymore; instead I practically live in Universal Standard, where I wear an S. (I also wear a 16W at Madewell and an 18 at Everlane, for comparison.)
Until recently, however, none of that really mattered. I worked from home for nearly a decade, so clothes shopping was more recreational than anything. I could always make my top half look professional enough for a Zoom meeting and wear something comfy on my bottom half. But I'm about to enter a whole new career that requires going into an office. Instead of hiding behind a computer, I'm going to be face to face with other human beings, staring straight at me, all day long. And they're going to be able to see my whole body!
For all those reasons, I was thrilled to try several pieces from Quince's extended size collection. A little cashmere, silk, and linen seemed like just what I need to build my new professional wardrobe. The plus size offerings are pretty limited, but I appreciated that it seems to include retailored versions of their best sellers: classic cashmere sweaters, silk blouses, and linen dresses. No weird tent dresses, jungle prints, or cold shoulders (sorry). Nothing cut to cover up. Just fuller shapes, modeled by fuller women.
Quince Plus Size Washable Silk Skirt
Unfortunately, none of the pants were appealing to me at all. I mean, I would normally love a classic wide-legged linen pant, but even on the models they seem to pull and stretch at the hips and thighs. How would they look on my non-model bottom half?
Instead I chose the Washable Silk Skirt in Hot Fudge ($69.90). I took a chance on the 1X, even though my hips would put me in a 2X, and I'm glad I did. It's cut on the bias, so it has just enough stretch to glide over my hips, and the fit across my belly is comfy enough that I can imagine tucking shirts in (imagine!).
Not only that, this skirt is cut 1.5 inches longer in the back to accommodate the booty and still hang straight at the hem. You'd think that would be standard tailoring practice, but if your butt is like mine, you know that at this price point it is not. I am going to get a ton of wear out of this skirt.
Quince Plus Size Washable Stretch Silk Notch Collar Blouse
I paired the skirt with a Washable Stretch Silk Notch Collar Blouse in Ivory in 1X ($82), because who doesn't need another classic white shirt. One thing many brands get wrong when they size their clothes up is the armscye. (Maybe that explains all those weird cold shoulders?) But the shoulder points hit me right where they should and the arms move comfortably with me, without pulling weirdly across the front or the back.
Regrettably, this blouse on its own is too sheer for work (but, as my 21-year-old daughter pointed out, not sheer enough to be fun). I'll always have to wear a cami under it, which causes a little bit of a problem with the neck opening.
Quince Mongolian Cashmere V-Neck Sweater in Heather Vintage Pink
I was all ready for the Mongolian Cashmere V-Neck Sweater in Heather Vintage Pink (also 1X) to become my new all-time favorite sweater. I was expecting cloud-soft coziness, and this is more lightweight and functional; so lightweight, in fact, that it almost becomes non-functional, because this, too, is sheer enough that I need a cami underneath it. But I love the fit and the drape and have already reached for it three times, in this in-between spring weather, since it arrived.
Quince Plus Size Mongolian Cashmere Full-Zip Hoodie
Another piece I was excited to unpack was the Mongolian Cashmere Full-Zip Hoodie in Rich Burgundy in 1X ($129). The higher price point brings a heavier weight knit and a richer softness. Cashmere hoodie! It's like all the best kinds of self-care in two little words. Unfortunately, the sleeves let me down here. I'm 5'9″, with longish arms and legs, which means I'm used to scrutinizing cuffs to see where they hit in model photos before I buy.
The cuffs on all the other tops hit me at the wrist, but not so for the hoodie. This may not be office wear (or is it now? It's been so long!), but I'm already looking forward to coming home after a long day and relaxing in a cashmere hoodie. (I'll just have to push up the sleeves.)
Quince Plus Size 100% European Linen Scoop Neck Midi Dress
The dress I chose took me way out of my comfort zone. I haven't worn anything sleeveless since… ever. I don't know if I have ever felt comfortable going sleeveless in public. But, honestly, it was completely out of character for me to agree to have my pictures posted online, so I thought, in for a penny, in for a pound.
The 100% European Linen Scoop Neck Midi Dress in Deep Navy in 1X ($84) is beautifully constructed: fully lined, top stitched, elastic ruching across the back, and slashed pockets (instead of the cheaper and easier side-seam pockets). I was nervous about the fit across the hip in a 1X, but the bottom is cut to sit out from the body in a very subtle tulip shape. It's comfortable, and flattering… and I still think I'm going to need to find a jacket to wear over the top, but that's my own issue.
Quince Italian Leather Bow Penny Loafer and Voyage Nylon Travel Tote
I wore all of these with Italian Leather Bow Penny Loafers in Bone ($92) and the Voyage Nylon Travel Tote in Navy ($98). I have yet to put the shoes through a full day's work at the office, but the fit was comfortable enough right out of the box and fun to pair with both the skirt and jeans.
The bag splits the difference between a work tote and a carry-on. I can easily fit an outfit for one or two overnights, but at the same time it doesn't look too ludicrously capacious for daily use. I'm excited to use it for travel, because it's been hard to find a bag that can do double duty as a plane carry-on and a walking-about-town bag. I think this one fits the bill.
Overall, Quince has done a great job bringing its “inexpensive expensive” wardrobe staples to larger customers. The quality, for the most part, exceeds the price, and I expect to get a lot of wear out of all of these pieces.
You May Also Like:
Thank you, Tricia, for doing this with such honesty and a great eye. The photos are gorgeous, and I know this review is going to help a lot of people make more confident decisions before they click buy.
A couple of things worth adding from my end: Quince's extended size collection is a separate section of their site, and the prices do run about $10 higher than the standard sizes for equivalent pieces. I am not a fan of this “tax,” but sadly it is common across many apparel retailers. In some places the collection is called extended size; in other places Quince calls it plus size. The size range tops out at 3X (US 24), which, as many of you have pointed out to me, excludes a significant percentage of those who deserve these quality basics.
The color range is also far more limited than the misses offerings. That being said, when the original Quince plus size review was shared in 2024 by Community member Kathryn, the extended size collection has quadrupled in size and a few more colors have been added to the mix. I hope Quince continues to expand this collection.
If you've ordered from Quince's plus size collection, I want to hear from you. What worked, what didn't, and what do you wish they would add? Drop it in the comments. Your experience is exactly what the next person searching this needs to read!
FAQ About the Quince Plus Size Collection
Does Quince have plus sizes?
Yes. Quince offers extended sizes in 1X–3X, which corresponds to approximately US 16–24. The extended size collection is a separate section of their site and includes select best-sellers in cashmere, silk, linen, and more.
Is Quince true to size in extended sizes?
It depends on the piece. Community member Tricia (size 1X, 40″ waist, 49″ hips) found the silk skirt ran small through the hips and sized down from a 2X to a 1X. The cashmere hoodie ran long in the sleeves for her 5'9″ frame. Always check the individual size chart for extended sizes, which is separate from Quince's standard size chart.
Does Quince extended size cost more than regular sizes?
Yes. Quince's extended sizes are priced approximately $10 higher than equivalent pieces in standard sizes.
Is Quince good quality for plus size clothing?
Based on this review, yes. The linen dress, silk skirt, and cashmere hoodie in particular received high marks for construction and fit. The cashmere v-neck sweater runs lighter weight than expected and may require a cami underneath. As someone who is a midsize 14/16, I have found the same quality in the standard collection so it's consistent across the board for Quince women's apparel.
Did you like what you just read?
Consider tapping here to buy me a coffee in thanks. The best gift you can give a content creator is the gift of sharing. Consider sharing this article on Facebook or Pinterest. Thank you so much for your support!
Thanks for the review, Tricia! I’ve been looking for a silk shirt (but washable because I know myself and I will never get around to going to the dry cleaners!).
I’d love to know where your jeans are from, the cut is just what I’m looking for.
Hi, Jenny! The silk shirt is labeled as washable, but I haven’t been brave enough to throw it in the washer yet. I’ll send Alison an update when I do.
The jeans are Carrie wide leg jeans from Universal Standard. (Mine are a size 14, because they run pretty big.) I wear them constantly!
Hi, Jenny! The silk says it’s washable, but I haven’t been brave enough to throw it in the wash yet. I’ll send Alison an update when I do.
My jeans are the Carrie wide-legs from Universal Standard (size 14, because they run really big). I wear them constantly with absolutely everything. They’re pricey, so I would watch for a denim sale or join the buy/sell/trade group on Facebook.
Thanks for the helpfully honest review, Tricia!
In the future though Alison, would it be possible for others’ reviews to include photos from different angles? I think that would better help the rest of us to assess fit before buying.
It doesn’t need to be the 360 degree GIFs that you upload for your own reviews (though those are definitely appreciated!) but even just some side and back views can help to tell whether the sleeves would be too long or if the back will need to ve adjusted.
When it comes to reader reviews, I let them choose what photos make them comfortable. I give some guidelines and will suggest this, but I know how hard it is to be on the internet, and want to make sure they feel good about every picture they provide. This is a good suggestion, I will add it to the potential pose list!
I loved this review. I found Quince because of Alison! I ordered a creamy capsule this winter and took some amazing photos in the silk dress and v-neck cashmere sweater. I have had to return a cashmere sweater due to a hole (after one wear and nothing I did caused the problem) and the process was super easy. The sizing works for my apple shaped body and I am a true 2X. I do wish they offered more in plus sizes. Your review was honest and thorough and I enjoyed it. I am wondering if the darker colored silk blouses would have the same see through effect now as I liked the shape of it. Do you feel it’s worth trying for the expense? The silk dress is amazing. It was a brave choice for me but this group has inspired me in so many ways! Ordering the linen one that you tried on too!
It’s hard to say whether the darker blouses might be less see-through, but my best guess would be yes. I really like the cut, so it’s worth trying. (And they’re returnable!)
I have one of the Quince silk dresses in black and it’s opaque enough that I don’t feel I need a slip or to worry about the color of my undergarments. I haven’t tried any other silk tops from Quince… yet!
Thank you so much for your review! It is so helpful having a real live person share their thoughts on fit, feel, quality, etc. Kudos to you for stepping out of your comfort zone!
Excellent review from a “real size” person. I received my first Quince order a couple of days ago. No luck with pants, jodphur-looking on my shape. I’m keeping the lightweight cotton cashmere sweater in yellow because it’s pretty. It’s also very thin fabric and I’ll wear it over something.
I finally did the big shopping after getting rid of all my non-fitting and worn out clothes and I am in a terrible mood. I knew exactly what I wanted for a core wardrobe. Four pair of black pants were returned, some jeans I thought would be ok with a hot water shrinking wash failed entirely. Since I’d washed them, they went in the giveaway stack.
My initial thought was as a grown-ass woman I’d upgrade to fewer, more expensive pieces. Unfortunately, it turns out I have a discount-store body and Saks and Neiman Marcus won’t work. Back to Lands End petites, I guess.
I’d suggest to Tricia that she try the 100% European Linen Short Sleeve Shirt as a topper for the scoop neck linen dress. I, too, was a bit apprehensive about wearing a sleeveless dress but it looked so nice that I jumped in and got the navy one. I already had the short sleeve shirt from a previous year’s purchase and decided to pair the two. I have since purchased both items in white. Not only does the shirt cover the arms that I am loathe to put on display, it also provides shoulder protection in places that have a bit too much air-conditioning, and looks like a professional ensemble in the workplace.
Thank you! I think I’ll give it a try. I like the cut of the linen camp shirt better, but they haven’t added that to their plus-size line!
Great review by a real person! I love that silk skirt. As a 4’11” person, I feel Quince does not truly have “extended” sizing. They have a handful of “petite” pants that still need to shortened by about 6″. I have to wear a L or XL in Quince sizing, and the proportions are all off for a short person. The average height in the US is 5′ 4″ , but companies seem to ignore this large population. Thank you again for the honest review. Hopefully, Quince will get the idea of designing thoughtfully for petites – and not just the skinny ones. Companies seem to forget that petites come in all shapes.
Fully agree, Debra!
I have left similar comments about many companies. Don’t pretend that your models now represent the population when the shortest is 5’8”. Don’t pretend that 16 is the outer limits of sizing. Get the stats and meet the need, and show us what the clothes look like on models the sizes of the population.
Thanx for the review, and putting yourself out there with pics! Scrolling, the article seemed like it would be dry with only text and catalog photos . . . Alison kept us in suspensem until the fist photo was revealed. My fav it the cotton knit blazer. It looks good open like in the first photo with the purse, closed like in the last photo . . . How would it look belted? I wonder if you could sew buttons or loop closures hidden on the inside. Such a sophisticated tan! Quince came up with a lovely neutral . . . that would balance a patterned sweater or skirt. The length is perfect! It is elongating, slimming.
Great review of your items Kathryn and thank you Alison for inviting her to do this and for giving us more information on the Quince line. I am becoming obsessed with their line of clothing! So many pretty and luxurious items to choose from. Right up my alley…lol!
Tricia, you look fantastic! Thank you for sharing your thoughts and lovely photos.
I also am starting a new job with a more elevated dress code; you have inspired me.
Aw, thank you! Good luck with your new job!
Thank you so much for taking the time to review this line! I’m similar size to you — 5’5″ and size 24, so this was especially useful. I love how that wrap dress looks on you, so I’m definitely going to check it out for myself ;)!
Love the dress! Absolute favorite. My question, is it a true wrap or faux wrap? If a true wrap does it feel and look like it will stay closed without adjusting all day long?
It’s a true wrap! It stayed put just fine on me. 🙂
What a wonderful and helpful review, Kathryn! Thanks for providing her with your platform, Alison. I have been obsessed with Quince since the outset of the pandemic and am thrilled that they’re also offering the extended sizes that Kathryn completely rocked. Love Quince, love this post.
I have a couple of their sweaters and the v-neck Mongolian cashmere is so soft and warm. It pills very easily with a cross-body purse rubbing on the shoulder and the side. It also pilled a lot under the arms but a sweater shaver took care of it and it’s back to looking great. I have the navy fishterman’s sweater and love the fabric and color. The neck area is slighly too fitted around my neck, but I have issues with anything around my neck, so that’s more on me.
I loved this review and may need to try that silk skirt.
Even though I can’t order from this collection (neither in the USA nor plus sized) I nonetheless read every word here with joy – wish I could order these too, so consider me #influenced!
Are you sure you aren’t a professional blogger yourself, Kathryn? Because you’ve definitely found your ‘voice’ with your humorous yet informative writing style – more, please (if possible)!
Aww, thank you! I used to blog regularly but haven’t really made time for it after having kids. Maybe I’ll pick it up again someday soon!
I appreciate everything about this review! Great job, Kathryn! I’ve been eyeing that wrap dress for a while and reading your review was so helpful!
Kathryn, you should be a regular guest writer for Alison! You are articulate and an excellent writer. This was a very enjoyable read. Well done!
Great review, would love to know how items were post washing a few times
Thank you Kathryn, for the real-woman real-life honest review… love that olive wrap dress! And also thank you Alison, for opportunities like this for other followers and fashionistas to collaborate with you!
This is such an excellent and helpful review – thank you Kathryn (and Alison)! Despite the many ads I’ve been served this is the first time I’ve been tempted to try Quince. I agree with the other commenters that the feedback Kathryn provided is just what I need to know to make an informed choice. That wrap dress really does look like perfection – thanks for mentioning that it comes in navy (olive is just not my jam).
Kathryn, what a great review! Your information is helpful & I love your sense of humor too (“I’m not a regular neutral, I’m a cool neutral”)! The pieces you chose are lovely and definitely seem like ones you’ll actually enjoy wearing. And, they do all seem like pieces that will give you lots of options in your wardrobe. Alison, thank you doing a review this way for us.
What a lovely review, Kathryn! I have had my eye on that skirt for a while and I appreciate the comment about the length based on your height – that is the kind of feedback I appreciate when considering a purchase.
Kudos on a terrific review- both content and writing style!
I am now “influenced” to explore the Quince website, and I’m already craving that silk skirt and the cardigan. I’m 5’10” and a decade older than you but your analysis of these pieces made it easy for me to visualize them in my life. Thanks to you for the review and to Alison for creating the opportunity!
Thank you for such a great review! I always love to see clothes on non-model bodies, and everything looks great on you, Kathryn. I’m definitely checking out that cardigan.
Great review! I am a Quince fan. You killed me with the secret lollipop stash—-I spent so much time in my younger years worried that the tampons would spill and now I too worry that my candy will spill out!! I feel you!!
What a fantastic review, Well written and informative.! And you have definitely influenced me to take a look at that blazer. And that sweater. I am a little bit taller than you and so they might be absolutely perfect.
Great review, and the clothes look terrific on you, Kathryn! Thanks for doing this. Consider me #influenced – I think I need that cashmere cardigan.
Thanks for the great review, and the opportunity for a non-blogger “regular lady” to review Quince. I’ve clicked on many bloggers’ reviews of Quince, but have never found anything I wanted shown in extended sizes, and was sure that Quince didn’t even offer anything over size 16 or so. It had gotten to the point, that this week, I deleted three different emails from bloggers who reviewed Quince, certain that it was pointless. What perfect timing Alison, and your heading made all the difference to me. I will certainly be visiting Quince to look specifically for extended size clothing. What an eye opener. Thanks so much!
Great review Kathryn! I can relate to your challenges and desire for elevated basics. You made great choices & I love to se how the fit works for a plus size, 5’6″ body. Fit models are generally on the tall size so it can be hard to determine the actual length of the clothes. You look fantastic & helped me see how Quince clothing would fit me.
Thank you Kathryn for being willing to put your self out there and write and model this review for us.
Thank you Allison for offering this for organizing, arranging and offering the space for this review.